Why We Replace Both Garage Door Springs
Updated: 17 hours ago
When one spring on a two-spring garage door breaks, we recommend replacing both. The two springs were installed together, have been through the same number of cycles and carry the load together, so the second one is almost always near the end of its life too. Replacing only one often means a second service call within months, and an unbalanced door in the meantime.
Why do garage doors have two springs?
Most double-wide doors use two torsion springs on the same bar, one on each side of the centre bracket. Together they supply the lifting force that makes a heavy door feel nearly weightless. Each one carries about half of the work, so when one lets go, the other is suddenly doing all of it. Some doors, mostly narrower single doors, use a single wider spring, and in that case there is simply one to replace.
Is the second spring really about to fail?
Very often, yes. Springs are rated in cycles, and both springs have used up the same number. They are the same wire, the same age and have lived in the same cold garage. One happened to give out first because of a tiny flaw or a spot of rust. The survivor has only slightly more life left, and it now takes extra strain. You can read about those ratings in our post on how long garage door springs last.
What happens if I only replace one spring?
You end up with two springs of different ages and different tension, so the door can be hard to balance and may close crooked. The old one will probably break soon, which means paying for a second visit. Mixed springs can also wear the cables, drums and opener unevenly. The problems we see most often are:
A door that lifts on one side first and looks twisted as it opens.
An opener that strains because the springs no longer match.
A second breakage a few weeks or months later, often on a cold morning.
Is it safe to replace a garage door spring myself?
No. Torsion springs hold a large amount of stored energy, and the winding bars that release it can slip and cause serious injuries. Technicians use properly fitting winding bars, the right spring for the exact door weight and the correct number of turns. If a spring has already broken, the safest first step is to stop using the door and call us. Our post on a broken garage door spring covers what to do in the meantime.
How does the technician match the new springs to my door?
The springs are chosen by door weight, door height and drum size, not by looking at the old ones. The old springs may have been wrong for the door in the first place, especially on a builder-grade door that later gained insulation or a window. We weigh the door, measure the wire and coil length, and choose a spring that balances it so the door stays put halfway up.
What else gets checked at the same visit?
Since the springs are being replaced, it is the right time to inspect the parts that work with them. We look at the cables for fraying, the drums for wear, the centre and end bearings, the rollers and hinges, and the opener's force settings. A frayed cable or worn bearing left in place can shorten the life of brand new springs, and our post on garage door cable repair explains what we look for.
Can the door be balanced properly afterwards?
Yes, and it is the last step of the job. With the opener disconnected, the door should stay still when lifted to about waist height and should move smoothly through the whole travel. If it drifts up or down, the tension is adjusted until it holds. A balanced door puts less load on the opener, the cables and the track.
More on the service: garage door spring replacement, open 24/7 across the GTA.
Call Modern Empire Doors for a spring replacement
When choosing new springs, you may also want to read high-cycle garage door springs: are they worth it?.
Modern Empire Doors is at 138 Yorkland St, Richmond Hill. We are top rated on Google, have served the GTA since 2018, and answer 24/7 at 647-323-1826. Send a photo of the door from inside and outside, and a clear shot of the spring bar if you can, and we will tell you what the job involves before we head over.



Comments