Torsion vs Extension Springs: Which Is Better?
Updated: 17 hours ago
Torsion springs and extension springs do the same job, which is to balance the weight of the garage door so the opener or your arms can lift it, but they work differently. A torsion spring is mounted on a bar above the door and twists to store energy. An extension spring runs along each horizontal track and stretches. For most homes, torsion springs are the smoother and more controlled choice, while extension springs are common on older or lighter doors.
How does a torsion spring work?
A torsion spring is a coil mounted on a steel shaft above the closed door. As the door lowers, cables wound on drums at each end of the shaft wind the spring tighter. As the door rises, the spring unwinds and gives back that stored energy to lift the door's weight. Because the energy is released along the shaft in a controlled way, torsion doors tend to move smoothly and evenly.
How does an extension spring work?
An extension spring is a long coil that sits along each side of the door, parallel to the horizontal tracks. As the door lowers, the springs stretch. As it rises, they contract and help lift it. Pulleys and cables run through the system to keep both sides balanced. You will often see them on older homes and lighter single doors.
What are the main differences between them?
Location: torsion springs are above the door; extension springs run along the side tracks
Motion: torsion springs twist; extension springs stretch and contract
Door feel: torsion doors usually run smoother and quieter and stay better balanced
Door weight: torsion suits heavier insulated and wood doors; extension suits lighter doors
Headroom: extension systems need little space above the door; torsion needs room for the shaft
Which type is safer?
Torsion springs are generally considered the safer system when the spring breaks, because the spring stays on the shaft. A broken extension spring can whip free and fly across the garage unless it is held by a safety cable running through its centre. Both types hold dangerous tension and both should only be adjusted or replaced by a trained technician with the right winding bars and tools.
How can I tell which type I have?
Look at the garage with the door closed. A thick coil on a bar above the door, usually near the centre, means torsion. Long, thin coils on each side along the tracks, with pulleys at the ends, mean extension. If you see neither, the door may have another setup, so send us a photo.
Can I switch from extension to torsion springs?
In many cases, yes. A conversion adds a torsion shaft, drums and cables above the door and removes the extension springs and pulleys. It needs enough headroom and a suitable door, so a technician has to check the space and the door's weight first. Many homeowners switch for smoother operation and a safer failure mode.
What happens when a spring breaks?
The door becomes very heavy and the opener may hum without lifting it. You may hear a loud bang from the garage when it happens. Stop using the door and keep people and vehicles clear. We explain the steps in our guide on what to do about a broken garage door spring. If your door feels heavy before anything has snapped, see why a garage door is heavy to lift.
How do I keep springs working longer?
Lubricate the springs and moving parts a couple of times a year
Test the balance: with the opener disconnected and the door closed, it should lift smoothly and stay put when partly open
Replace springs in pairs when the door has two, since the second is usually as worn as the first
Add a seasonal check to your routine, as described in our garage door maintenance checklist
More on the service: garage door spring replacement, open 24/7 across the GTA.
Need help with garage door springs?
Want springs that last longer? See high-cycle garage door springs.
Modern Empire Doors, at 138 Yorkland St in Richmond Hill, is available 24/7 at 647-323-1826 and has served the GTA since 2018. We are top rated on Google. Send us a photo of the door from inside and outside, with the spring area in view, and we can tell you which system you have and what it needs.



Comments